There are 2 comments.
 
 
XWiki Platform / cid:jira-generated-image-avatar-8b4445dc-a94d-4200-841c-ebb9763da23f XWIKI-23954 Open

Don't underline inline links by default

 
View issue   ยท   Add comment
 

2 comments

 
cid:jira-generated-image-avatar-85dfcf49-5c2d-42c6-bcc3-88de5ac6acf1 Charpentier Lucas on 28/Jan/26 12:14
 

> By default links are underlined, which in some cases may not look good, clutters the display or simply the line goes beyond text.

We couldn't implement a perfect system. We decided to push it as it was good enough for XWiki Standard. However it was expected to improve it based on feedback we get. Can you share details about the situation where those inconsistencies show up so we can fix them for everyone?

> While the feature is very nice for accessibility reasons shouldn't be default for all users but activated for users who need it.

I don't agree. XWiki should be accessible by default. For this specific case it's not that bad, but how could you activate the accessibility feature on your profile if you cannot use the tool? It becomes a bareer to entry where disabled users need abled users to configure their profile so that they can start using the wiki. I can understand providing an option so that it's easy for admins to change this default, but I disagree fully with having a non-accessible default.

> Also with the current behavior it's very hard to disable this feature for all users since there is no global option to change it.

JS just started a topic on the forum on this subject, it'd be great to share your point of view on this here!

 
cid:jira-generated-image-avatar-85dfcf49-5c2d-42c6-bcc3-88de5ac6acf1 Charpentier Lucas on 28/Jan/26 12:15
 
> By default links are underlined, which in some cases may not look good, clutters the display or simply the line goes beyond text.

We couldn't implement a perfect system. We decided to push it as it was good enough for XWiki Standard. However it was expected to improve it based on feedback we get. Can you share details about the situation where those inconsistencies show up so we
can fix them may improve the system for everyone?

> While the feature is very nice for accessibility reasons shouldn't be default for all users but activated for users who need it.

I don't agree. XWiki should be accessible by default. For this specific case it's not that bad, but how could you activate the accessibility feature on your profile if you cannot use the tool? It becomes a bareer to entry where disabled users need abled users to configure their profile so that they can start using the wiki. I can understand providing an option so that it's easy for admins to change this default, but I disagree fully with having a non-accessible default.

> Also with the current behavior it's very hard to disable this feature for all users since there is no global option to change it.

JS just started [a topic on the forum|https://forum.xwiki.org/t/proposal-for-a-global-setting-for-links-underlining-preferences/18170] on this subject, it'd be great to share your point of view on this here!