[xwiki-devs] [Proposal] XE 2.3 Updated Roadmap
Hi, Since today is the day we're supposed to release XE 2.3M2 and since we've released 3.2M1 quite late compared to the original date we need to decide what we do from now on. Original dates: * XE 2.3M1: 8 March 2010 (1 month after XE 2.2 final) * XE 2.3M2: 29 March 2010 * XE 2.3RC1: 12 April 2010 * XE 2.3 RC2/Final: 26 April 2010 Here's my proposal: * We have enough new features already (captcha in comments, new theme editor, annotation features, any char supported un doc names, lots of rendering fixes, etc) to justify a final XE 2.3 release * I suggest Thomas finishes putting our Lucene search as the default search since it's now working well enough. AFAIK Thomas is only missing an admin screen to finish it. * I suggest we don't have more new features (unless someone has something that can be committed this week - Caleb: what about the invitation feature?) * I suggest we release: ** XE 2.3M2 on the 5th of April ** XE 2.3RC1 on the 12th of April (one week after) ** XE 2.3RC2/final on the 19th of April (and in case we have problems we can delay by one week till the 26th of April) WDYT? Thanks -Vincent
JV. On Mon, Mar 29, 2010 at 5:06 PM, Vincent Massol <vincent@massol.net> wrote:
Hi,
Since today is the day we're supposed to release XE 2.3M2 and since we've released 3.2M1 quite late compared to the original date we need to decide what we do from now on.
Original dates: * XE 2.3M1: 8 March 2010 (1 month after XE 2.2 final) * XE 2.3M2: 29 March 2010 * XE 2.3RC1: 12 April 2010 * XE 2.3 RC2/Final: 26 April 2010
Here's my proposal:
* We have enough new features already (captcha in comments, new theme editor, annotation features, any char supported un doc names, lots of rendering fixes, etc) to justify a final XE 2.3 release * I suggest Thomas finishes putting our Lucene search as the default search since it's now working well enough. AFAIK Thomas is only missing an admin screen to finish it. * I suggest we don't have more new features (unless someone has something that can be committed this week - Caleb: what about the invitation feature?) * I suggest we release: ** XE 2.3M2 on the 5th of April
I'd prefer 6th of april ;)
** XE 2.3RC1 on the 12th of April (one week after) ** XE 2.3RC2/final on the 19th of April (and in case we have problems we can delay by one week till the 26th of April)
WDYT?
Sounds good. +1, JV.
On Mon, Mar 29, 2010 at 17:06, Vincent Massol <vincent@massol.net> wrote:
Hi,
Since today is the day we're supposed to release XE 2.3M2 and since we've released 3.2M1 quite late compared to the original date we need to decide what we do from now on.
If we already released 3.2M1 we are not that late ;)
Original dates: * XE 2.3M1: 8 March 2010 (1 month after XE 2.2 final) * XE 2.3M2: 29 March 2010 * XE 2.3RC1: 12 April 2010 * XE 2.3 RC2/Final: 26 April 2010
Here's my proposal:
* We have enough new features already (captcha in comments, new theme editor, annotation features, any char supported un doc names, lots of rendering fixes, etc) to justify a final XE 2.3 release * I suggest Thomas finishes putting our Lucene search as the default search since it's now working well enough. AFAIK Thomas is only missing an admin screen to finish it. * I suggest we don't have more new features (unless someone has something that can be committed this week - Caleb: what about the invitation feature?) * I suggest we release: ** XE 2.3M2 on the 5th of April ** XE 2.3RC1 on the 12th of April (one week after) ** XE 2.3RC2/final on the 19th of April (and in case we have problems we can delay by one week till the 26th of April)
WDYT?
+1
Thanks -Vincent
_______________________________________________ devs mailing list devs@xwiki.org http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs
-- Thomas Mortagne
Vincent Massol wrote:
Hi,
Since today is the day we're supposed to release XE 2.3M2 and since we've released 3.2M1 quite late compared to the original date we need to decide what we do from now on.
Original dates: * XE 2.3M1: 8 March 2010 (1 month after XE 2.2 final) * XE 2.3M2: 29 March 2010 * XE 2.3RC1: 12 April 2010 * XE 2.3 RC2/Final: 26 April 2010
Here's my proposal:
* We have enough new features already (captcha in comments, new theme editor, annotation features, any char supported un doc names, lots of rendering fixes, etc) to justify a final XE 2.3 release * I suggest Thomas finishes putting our Lucene search as the default search since it's now working well enough. AFAIK Thomas is only missing an admin screen to finish it. * I suggest we don't have more new features (unless someone has something that can be committed this week - Caleb: what about the invitation feature?) I have code here working, saves the email, allows it to be reviewed by admins, allows reporting of spam, only needs to send the actual message ;)
Caleb
* I suggest we release: ** XE 2.3M2 on the 5th of April ** XE 2.3RC1 on the 12th of April (one week after) ** XE 2.3RC2/final on the 19th of April (and in case we have problems we can delay by one week till the 26th of April)
WDYT?
Thanks -Vincent
_______________________________________________ devs mailing list devs@xwiki.org http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs
Hi Caleb, On Mar 29, 2010, at 6:40 PM, Caleb James DeLisle wrote:
Vincent Massol wrote:
Hi,
Since today is the day we're supposed to release XE 2.3M2 and since we've released 3.2M1 quite late compared to the original date we need to decide what we do from now on.
Original dates: * XE 2.3M1: 8 March 2010 (1 month after XE 2.2 final) * XE 2.3M2: 29 March 2010 * XE 2.3RC1: 12 April 2010 * XE 2.3 RC2/Final: 26 April 2010
Here's my proposal:
* We have enough new features already (captcha in comments, new theme editor, annotation features, any char supported un doc names, lots of rendering fixes, etc) to justify a final XE 2.3 release * I suggest Thomas finishes putting our Lucene search as the default search since it's now working well enough. AFAIK Thomas is only missing an admin screen to finish it. * I suggest we don't have more new features (unless someone has something that can be committed this week - Caleb: what about the invitation feature?) I have code here working, saves the email, allows it to be reviewed by admins, allows reporting of spam, only needs to send the actual message ;)
The question is whether this will be 100% finished (i.e. voting time included if there are votes related to this, no hacks, no rushing, full testing) before end of the week? I think it's better not to include it if it's too rushed and instead postpone it to 2.4M1. OTOH it's nice to have it if it's done. Since this should be an extension, it could maybe even be released after the 2.3 release (unless there are "hardcoded" ties with the platform). Let us know what you wish to do. Thanks -Vincent
Caleb
* I suggest we release: ** XE 2.3M2 on the 5th of April ** XE 2.3RC1 on the 12th of April (one week after) ** XE 2.3RC2/final on the 19th of April (and in case we have problems we can delay by one week till the 26th of April)
WDYT?
Thanks -Vincent
Vincent Massol wrote:
Hi Caleb,
On Mar 29, 2010, at 6:40 PM, Caleb James DeLisle wrote:
Vincent Massol wrote:
Hi,
Since today is the day we're supposed to release XE 2.3M2 and since we've released 3.2M1 quite late compared to the original date we need to decide what we do from now on.
Original dates: * XE 2.3M1: 8 March 2010 (1 month after XE 2.2 final) * XE 2.3M2: 29 March 2010 * XE 2.3RC1: 12 April 2010 * XE 2.3 RC2/Final: 26 April 2010
Here's my proposal:
* We have enough new features already (captcha in comments, new theme editor, annotation features, any char supported un doc names, lots of rendering fixes, etc) to justify a final XE 2.3 release * I suggest Thomas finishes putting our Lucene search as the default search since it's now working well enough. AFAIK Thomas is only missing an admin screen to finish it. * I suggest we don't have more new features (unless someone has something that can be committed this week - Caleb: what about the invitation feature?) I have code here working, saves the email, allows it to be reviewed by admins, allows reporting of spam, only needs to send the actual message ;)
The question is whether this will be 100% finished (i.e. voting time included if there are votes related to this, no hacks, no rushing, full testing) before end of the week? I wouldn't feel confident that it's bug free by the end of the week. I guess we'd better leave it out for 2.4M1.
Caleb I think it's better not to include it if it's too rushed and instead postpone it to 2.4M1. OTOH it's nice to have it if it's done. Since this should be an extension, it could maybe even be released after the 2.3 release (unless there are "hardcoded" ties with the platform).
Let us know what you wish to do.
Thanks -Vincent
Caleb
* I suggest we release: ** XE 2.3M2 on the 5th of April ** XE 2.3RC1 on the 12th of April (one week after) ** XE 2.3RC2/final on the 19th of April (and in case we have problems we can delay by one week till the 26th of April)
WDYT?
Thanks -Vincent
_______________________________________________ devs mailing list devs@xwiki.org http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs
participants (4)
-
Caleb James DeLisle -
Jean-Vincent Drean -
Thomas Mortagne -
Vincent Massol